My ADSL speed creeps upward, almost at 2005 levels now

Internet, Local, Tech

I’ve often bitched about my connection to the intertubes being pretty slow compared to what is generally expected in the current times. As average download speeds have increased, I’ve found myself going to sites that assume faster download speeds than I have, and thus having to pause & come back to videos when they’ve buffered more to avoid an irritating stop-start experience (note to flash players that only allow buffering of a little bit of a video - shame on you). I jumped on the broadband wagon in 2001 at a downstream speed of 512k/s, and until now, in the intervening 6 and a bit years, the speed has only increased once to 1M/s. That’s pretty piss-poor, but the reality is that we’re an island, and even though we’ve been getting increased capacity via fibre-optic cable links to Europe, our shores are clogged with offshore finance businesses and gambling websites from other juristictions (hosted here for regulatory reasons) who are quite willing to soak up all this extra bandwidth through dedicated circuits at incredibly inflated prices, so the average consumer has been mostly forgotten.

Well, we’ve been tossed a bone finally and my downstream speed has now increased to 2M/s (unlimited), which is certainly welcome, but incredibly late and still below par considering I pay £22 per month for it - in comparison in the UK O2 will do 16M/s (unlimited) for £15pm. A quick test at SpeedTest.net (off-peak) indeed reported a decent performance, slightly off the max reported by my router:

I’m not sure why it thinks my ISP is in Slough, but there you go. The important fact, something I’ve banged on about for some time to our intransigent infrastructure supplier (Cable & Wireless, now rebranded as ‘Sure’ locally, which ironically is my exact response whenever their PR dept claims they’re building a ‘world class telecoms system’), is that we’re still running at about half the average speed of the UK and Europe, which is still pitiful. Yeah, I know there’s the island aspect, but that cuts both ways - the cables never have far to go here, certainly compared to the UK/Europe averages which include distant rural areas - even my parents can get up to 6.5M/s where they live, and they’re in a tiny village in rural Cornwall.  Plus, there’s also a captive market locally sloshing with shedloads of money from rich finance houses and related high-value services, which can easily fund investment - if there’s one place you could build a modern telecommunications infrastructure, it’s somewhere like this. But, they either can’t, or they’re not interested in doing so (for consumers), given that they can make their sackfuls of money from business links, and consumer services are small beer. That’s also why it’s almost impossible to rent a server cost-effectively over here, they’re only interested in (gambling) companies that will rent several racks at a time, small customers are irrelevant to them. Luckily that market is global - I can host pretty much anywhere and get a deal 10x better than I can locally - but when it comes to my local internet connection, I’m stuck with what we have.

I’m holding out for one of the competitors to put up a few high-speed wireless transmitters covering the whole island (not that difficult), using the bandwidth from the extra optical cable they’ve brought ashore in recent weeks, and completely bypass the physical cabling system that ‘Sure’ controls - maybe that will finally shake them out of their torpor and make them appreciate the consumer market again. But, my cynical mind thinks it’s more likely they’ll also chase the business customers first anyway since it has a greater return. Hmm.

Share this post: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • N4G
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Mixx
  • Google
  • blogmarks
  • Slashdot
  • Reddit

8 Responses to “My ADSL speed creeps upward, almost at 2005 levels now”

  1. Bazlurgan Says:
    May 21st, 2008 at 11:57 am

    It sucks, I know.

    The reality is that the average customer in Guernsey, just browsing the internet, probably doesn’t really care. It’s only a small minority that even notice. Also, most are also likely unaware of how far behind out broadband is compared to the rest of Europe.

    Whilst any improvement is good, like you say, it could still be a hell of a lot better.

  2. Steve Says:
    May 21st, 2008 at 12:06 pm

    I don’t agree with that explanation at all, if it was simply down to consumer apathy, the same situation would prevail across the UK and Europe since consumers are mostly the same everywhere. No, it’s simply a lack of proper competition in the physical infrastructure, when it comes down to it, Sure controls 80-90% of the price we actually pay and no-one else has any say over the physical availability. So if they drag their feet, everyone does. It’s the same problem they had in the UK with BT but that has progressed further in terms of unbundling, reduction of base costs and bandwidth availability. Personally I accuse Sure of hoarding all the bandwidth for their lucrative business customers which have higher margins, and because the other ISPs have no control whatsoever over that availability they can’t compete effectively. The regulator should be involved here, but they seem obsessed with mobile at the moment.

  3. Aranoth Says:
    May 21st, 2008 at 9:07 pm

    In France, even small villages can expect at least 8Mb/s. Often more, like 20Mb/s.
    But the fact is that a lot of people care about their connection (for what purpose ? I wonder…).

    We also had the same problem that you describe, Steve.
    France Telecom own the majority of the infrastructure (because it was a public service before) but the concurrence is aggressive, so they have to do concessions. In fact, France Telecom/Orange is penalized by the “free concurrence law” on each level.

  4. Damien Guard Says:
    May 21st, 2008 at 11:52 pm

    I just did a speed comparison from work:

    Your best download: 85995 kb/s, your best upload: 80821 kb/s. Your global rank: 99%

    Heh.

    [)amien

  5. Steve Says:
    May 22nd, 2008 at 8:19 am

    Gah. Must be why they don’t notice the service packs are so big ;)

  6. Dan Says:
    May 22nd, 2008 at 10:21 pm

    I’m at Fastest Download: 28679 kb/s, Fastest Upload: 9804 kb/s and those service packs are still a killer. :)

  7. Arthur Says:
    June 1st, 2008 at 11:38 am

    Here in my country (Brazil) I pay something like £20 to get 300Kb/s o.O

  8. Steve Says:
    June 1st, 2008 at 11:40 am

    Ouch :(

Leave a Reply